Homeless Statistics
…”It would be silly to argue that the
conventional wisdom is never true. But noticing where the conventional wisdom may be false—noticing,
perhaps, the contrails of sloppy or self-interested thinking—is a nice place to
start asking questions.
Consider the recent history of homelessness in
the United States. In the early 1980s, an advocate for the homeless named Mitch Snyder took to saying that there were about 3 million
homeless Americans. The public duly sat up and took notice. More than 1 of
every 100 people were homeless? That sure seemed high,
but . . . well, the expert said it. A heretofore quiescent problem was suddenly
catapulted into the national consciousness. Snyder even testified before
Congress about the magnitude of the
problem. He also reportedly told a college
audience that 45 homeless people die each second—which would mean a whopping
1.4 billion dead homeless every year. (The U.S. population at the time was about 225 million.) Assuming that Snyder
misspoke or was misquoted and meant to say that one homeless person died every forty-five
seconds, that's
still 701,000 dead homeless people every
year—roughly one-third of all deaths in the United States. Hmm! Ultimately, when
Snyder was pressed on his figure of 3 million
homeless, he admitted that it was a
fabrication. Journalists had been hounding him for a specific number, he said,
and he hadn't wanted them to walk away empty-handed.”
Freakonomics, Levitt
and Dubner, page 90