Comrade Capitalists
January 31, 2006; WSJ, Page A14
Though Mao Tse-tung's portrait still hangs in Tiananmen Square, a recent poll shows that the Chinese are
crazier about capitalism than are Americans. In fact, they top the world-wide
rankings in their zeal for free markets. No wonder Mao isn't
smiling.
In a poll conducted
for the University of Maryland's Program on International Policy Attitudes
between June and August last year, fully 74% of Chinese citizens said they
agreed with the statement "the free enterprise system and free market
economy is the best system on which to base the future of the world." The Philippines, at 73%, and the U.S., at 71%, were second and third. The poll,
which surveyed 20,791 people in 20 countries, seems like a pretty good snapshot
of current sentiment, as such things go.
Remarkable, isn't it,
that residents of the Middle Kingdom have maintained their appreciation of the
benefits of free enterprise through six decades of oppression and economic
backwardness imposed by their Communist cadres? Then again, for a culture in which
common New Year's greetings include "I wish you happiness and many
riches" and "may you make great profits," should we be
surprised? Most Hong
Kong residents
are spending the current Chinese New Year holiday politely distributing packets
of crisp new cash to friends and family. They have to earn this gift cash
somehow.
Less encouraging in
the Maryland survey was the response of Europeans, who
could use a dollop of capitalism given the sclerotic state of their older
economies. Fully half of the French disagreed that capitalism is the best way
forward. Italians and Spaniards were more supportive of Adam Smith's ideals,
with 59% and 63%, respectively, voting for free markets.
The survey contained
other telling nuggets, such as Russia and Brazil's irrational distrust of large companies.
Perhaps big corporations remind them too much of their countries' bureaucratic
workings. Strong support for government regulation of the environment shows as
well that there's a lot of education still to be done in explaining to citizens
why free-market countries also have the cleanest environments.
Mao
would probably turn over in his glass case if he realized that the Chinese have
rejected his teachings. But the harsh consequences those teachings imposed on
his countrymen have been an education like no other. Nothing creates eager
young capitalists quite like living under Communism.